The Latest on the Oakland County Commission

In 2028, we plan to support 19 candidates for the Oakland County Commission who are pro-privacy, pro-people and pro-democracy. Our monthly performance reviews function both to keep the public informed and to hold current commissioners accountable for their votes. Current commissioners who consistently uphold our three values will earn our support and those who do not will face a challenger.

Reading the Scores: Scores use a color scale. The darker the green, the more a commissioner voted in support of our value. The darker the red, the more they voted against it. Yellow, the middle of the scale, means a commissioner voted sometimes in support and sometimes against. The Total Score uses the same scale and is the average of the three value scores.

Each month we will post a graphic on our website and on social media which will show each commissioner’s Pro-Privacy, Pro-People, Pro-Democracy, and Total scores. For details on how each score was calculated, see the full spreadsheet which will be tabbed by month.

NOVEMBER Scoring

We scored each Oakland County Commissioner on three values, based on their votes and conduct at the November Board meeting on 11/19/2026. Want to watch it for yourself? Here's the video! Find agenda item numbers and more information in the agenda packet.

Pro-Privacy: There were no agenda items on this topic. Chair Woodward, Public Health & Safety Chair Penny Luebs, and Legislative Affairs Chair Brendan Johnson were rated based on their failure to advance any pro-privacy policies.

Pro-People: Scored on their votes on item 17a. Dissolution of the Department of Public Communications. Dissolving this department will result in at least six union-protected, merit-based positions being eliminated and replaced with political appointees. A "no" vote on 17a. supported our pro-people values.

Pro-Democracy: Scored on votes on Commissioner Nelson's motion to postpone 17a. A "yes" vote to postpone supports our pro-democracy values as the November Board of Commissioners meeting was rescheduled from 6pm to 9:30am which effectively prevented the impacted employees from attending the public hearing.

Total: The total score for each commissioner is the average of their scores for the month. Chair Dave Woodward lost additional points for removing item 14o and preventing discussion of the Cavell amendment to restore Cavell and Nelson to committees.

October Scoring

We scored each Oakland County Commissioner on three values, based on their votes and conduct at the October Board meeting on 10/15/2026. Want to watch it for yourself? Here's the video! Find agenda item numbers and more information in the agenda packet.

Pro-Privacy: Scored on two votes. A “no” on Item 15a, accepting a federal grant for CLEMIS, supported privacy because of concerns about how CLEMIS protects data. A “yes” on the amendment to Item 17c, which removed CHORUS, an AI tool with serious privacy issues, from a federal grant acceptance, also supported privacy.

Pro-People: Scored on the votes to accept four federal grants (Items 15a, 17b, 17c, and 17d). Each grant requires sharing information with ICE, so a “no” vote on each supported this value.

Pro-Democracy: Scored on votes on two discharge petitions: one for a whistleblower policy and one to prohibit ICE on county property without a warrant. A discharge would have allowed these items to be discussed and voted on. Voting against discharge blocked that discussion, which we consider anti-democratic. Because both petitions failed, we could not evaluate commissioners on the policies themselves. Commissioners Powell, Gershenson and Markham also lost points for leaving during public comment, and Chair Woodward lost points for improperly ending the first public comment period while audience members were still waiting to speak.

Privacy policy

PAID FOR BY I AM OAKLAND COUNTY 1129 W. 14 MILE #1042, CLAWSON, MI 48017